Played it, rated it

Reviews

The hosts’ verdicts on the games we’ve gone deep on, plus reviews from the VGP community. Every review has a score out of 10 and a word from the hosts' scale: Masterpiece, Standout, Enjoyable, Underwhelming, or Sucks.

• 

  From the Deep DiveGrand Theft Auto V

  Grand Theft Auto V, First Time in 2026: Ace's Unpopular Verdict

  Ace · Aug 24, 2026

  Rating: 7.5 out of 10, Underwhelming7.5/10Underwhelming
• 

  From the Deep DiveWhere Winds Meet

  Where Winds Meet Review: Beautiful, Bloated, and Not for Josh

  Josh · Jan 20, 2026

  Rating: 5 out of 10, Underwhelming5/10Underwhelming
• 

  From the Deep DiveThe Alters

  The Alters Review: A Masterpiece Two of Us Couldn't Stand

  Josh, Ryan and John · Jun 23, 2025

  Rating: 8 out of 10, Underwhelming8/10Underwhelming
• 

  From the Deep DiveThe Midnight Walk

  The Midnight Walk Review: Gorgeous Clay, Hollow Heart

  Ryan, Ace and John · May 14, 2025

  Rating: 6.5 out of 10, Underwhelming6.5/10Underwhelming
• 

  From the Deep DiveDragon Age: The Veilguard

  Dragon Age: The Veilguard Review: Mashed Potatoes With No Seasoning

  Josh, Ryan and Paul · Nov 18, 2024

  Rating: 6 out of 10, Underwhelming6/10Underwhelming

Games metadata is powered by IGDB.com (opens in a new tab)