How we review

Review policy

Last updated November 16, 2026

The short version: a score on this site is what the hosts think of the game, and nothing else. Nobody can buy a review, a score, or a place on a list.

What we review

The hosts pick the games: what they are playing, what listeners ask for, and what is new and worth talking about. Being sent a game does not mean it gets reviewed, and no one is promised coverage or a kind of coverage.

How we score

Reviews are scored out of 10, in half points, with a one-word verdict: Masterpiece, Standout, Enjoyable, Underwhelming, Sucks. A review from a Deep Dive episode carries the score the hosts gave on the show, and each host’s own score is shown beside it when they differ. A score is one person’s or one panel’s opinion after playing the game. We say when a review is based on part of a game, such as an early access build.

Games we are given

The hosts buy most of the games they play. Publishers and developers sometimes send a game before or at release. When they do, the review says Game provided by the publisher under the byline. A review with no such line is of a game the reviewer paid for.

A key gets a game a look. It does not buy a review, a score, or the timing of either. We keep embargoes we have agreed to, and we do not agree to ones that set what a review may say. We do not accept payment, gifts, or travel in return for a review.

Reviews also say where the game was played (PC, PlayStation, Xbox, Nintendo Switch, Steam Deck, Mobile, VR), since a game can run differently on each.

Sponsors and ads

The show runs ads, and some are read by the hosts. An ad, a sponsor, or a discount code never changes a score, a review, the Hottest games list, the Leaderboard, or an award. If a sponsor is the publisher of a game we review, the review says so.

The Spotlight and paid placements

The Spotlight on the home page features one game at a time. Most of the time it is a Hosts’ pick: a game the hosts chose, and nobody paid for it. When a company pays for the Spotlight, it is labelled “Presented by” with the company’s name, and the game’s card and any review of that game on this site say so too.

A paid Spotlight buys that space for a set time and nothing else. It does not buy a review, a score, a place on the Hottest list or the Leaderboard, or what the hosts say on the show.

Community reviews and ratings

Members write reviews too. A community review is the member’s own opinion and is marked as one; a host reads it before it is published, for the community rules, not to change the score. A member who was given the game says so the same way. Community ratings are the average of members’ own ratings and show once three members have rated a game.

Fixing mistakes

If a review gets a fact wrong, tell us and we will fix it. A score changes only when the reviewer plays more of the game and changes their mind, and the review says when that happens.

Send a game, or ask a question

Publishers and developers: see Work with us, or email info@videogamerspod.com.